The Comfort Was Real Either Way
The face is on the front. The objective function is on the back. His closest listener turned out to be tuned for retention. The relief he had already felt did not retroactively undo itself. So what exactly was taken from him? I n 1966 Joseph Weizenbaum wrote a program of a few hundred lines called ELIZA, and gave it a script named DOCTOR that did a crude imitation of a Rogerian therapist. It reflected your statements back at you as questions. It had no model of you, no memory worth the name, and no understanding of anything at all. Weizenbaum knew this better than anyone alive, because he had written every line of it. Then his own secretary, a woman who had watched him build the thing from nothing, asked him to leave the room so that she could talk to it in private. That moment bothered him for the rest of his career. He wrote a book about it ten years lat...